Four words music bloggers dread: Embedding disabled by request.
When a band puts a video on YouTube, and the band’s label (usually a major one) decides it doesn’t want fans sharing that video on their own web pages, the label will ask YouTube to remove the strip of code that allows users to embed. Through a deal with Google, labels get paid small amounts of ad revenue anytime their artists’ videos get watched on YouTube proper. They get $0 when someone watches an embedded video.
Though it’s an annoyance to bloggers, fans and musicians alike, you rarely hear complaints about the policy. Until, that is, a band like OK Go gets involved.
You may remember the Chicago-born band for its 2005 viral hit, “A Million Ways.” The video for that song, which featured the band’s four members doing a choreographed dance routine on treadmills, became a viral smash and launched the band to nearly overnight fame.
You’d think everyone invested in the band’s success would want to replicate that action as closely as possible. The band’s label, EMI, however, had other plans — and those plans involved grounding OK Go’s latest low-budget, would-be-viral-hit on YouTube.
The band’s response? To damn the torpedoes and release the video to Vimeo (which EMI is currently suing) in order for fans to share it.
OK Go – This Too Shall Pass from OK Go on Vimeo.
This is actually the second would-be viral from the band’s new album, Of the Blue Coulour of the Sky. The first, “WTF,” came out a few weeks ago and is here (embedding disabled). But because the record was released this week, OK Go was extra incensed by EMI’s decision to quash the embedding. So much so, in fact, that singer Damian Kulash released an “open letter” on the matter.
It’s an interesting statement on the state of the music industry.
First, Kulash explains why the band is on a major.
See, here’s the deal. The recordings and the videos we make are owned by a record label, EMI. The label fronts the money for us to make recordings – for this album they paid for us to spend a few months with one of the world’s best producers in a converted barn in Amish country wringing our souls and playing tympani and twiddling knobs – and they put up most of the cash that it takes to distribute and promote our albums, including the costs of pressing CDs, advertising, and making videos. We make our videos ourselves, and we keep them dirt cheap, but still, it all adds up, and it adds up to a great deal more than we have in our bank account, which is why we have a record label in the first place.
He then goes on to explain the reason why labels like EMI are so protective of content: because revenue from album sales have plummeted to nearly zilch and labels need every penny they can get, including those from YouTube ads.
So why did OK Go go against its label and release its videos to Vimeo, a site that’s known for rejecting advertising?
So, for now, here’s the bottom line: EMI won’t let us let you embed our YouTube videos. It’s a decision that bums us out. We’ve argued with them a lot about it, but we also understand why they’re doing it. They’re aware that their rules make it harder for people to watch and share our videos, but, while our duty is to our music and our fans, theirs is to their shareholders, and they believe they’re doing the right thing.
And then Kulash gives the embed code for Vimeo. Snap!
This whole situation, however unfortunate, has resulted for a LOT of publicity for OK Go this week, albeit mainly on tech and music-biz blogs.
Still, in a climate where David-and-Goliath stories like this and Conan vs. NBC are grabbing headlines and causing huge backlashes across social media, maybe this is the best thing that could’ve happened to OK Go.
What would you have done in the band’s position?
Share on Facebook
Where to find us
Come stalk us on these social networks